What is actually different?

FeatureCeraVe PMVanicream Daily Facial Moisturizer
Formula comparedUS PM Facial Moisturizing LotionDaily Facial Moisturizer, not the SPF 30 product
Shared ingredientsGlycerin, hyaluronic acid and ceramidesGlycerin, hyaluronic acid and ceramides
Notable differencesNiacinamide, dimethicone and cholesterol; three ceramidesSqualane; five ceramides; no niacinamide in the listed formula
Ingredient strengthPercentages not statedPercentages not stated
TextureLightweight, oil free lotionRich but lightweight, non greasy lotion
Fragrance and botanicalsNo added fragranceNo botanical extracts or essential oils; no fragrance in the listed formula
DirectionsApply liberally to face and neck at nightApply as needed day or night; can be used twice daily
Price information$19.99 listed, without a size alongside that priceNo price listed; a fair price per ounce comparison is unavailable
12

Both are lightweight lotions, despite CeraVe giving its lotion the additional job title of "night cream". Vanicream describes a quick absorbing finish suitable under makeup. CeraVe emphasizes continuous overnight hydration through its controlled release technology.12

CeraVe PM vs Vanicream Daily Facial Moisturizer for sensitive skin

Vanicream is the more straightforward choice if avoiding niacinamide is your priority. It is formulated for sensitive skin and has the National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance. CeraVe PM is also free of added fragrance; its niacinamide may help calm skin and reduce moisture loss. Neither designation means a moisturizer cannot irritate you. For known allergies, check the full package ingredient list rather than choosing by the sensitive skin wording alone.124

CeraVe PM vs Vanicream Daily Facial Moisturizer for dry skin in winter

Either lotion is a reasonable option for facial dryness when a lightweight texture is enough. If your face stays dry, flaky or tight, choose a heavier cream or ointment instead of assuming Vanicream's five ceramides make it the winter winner. Ceramides help retain moisture, but these formulas have no direct comparison showing which hydrates better.45

Cold outdoor air and indoor heating both reduce humidity. Apply moisturizer immediately after washing, use warm rather than hot water, and avoid scrubbing away flakes. A bedroom humidifier can help; clean it regularly. If exfoliating acids are making winter dryness worse, cut back rather than expecting a lotion to cancel out the irritation.356

How do you fit either into your routine?

  1. 1Wash gently. For dry skin, pat dry while leaving a little moisture on the skin.
  2. 2Follow your treatment's directions. CeraVe places PM after treatment; Vanicream places its lotion after serum.
  3. 3Apply CeraVe PM liberally to the face and neck at night, or as your physician directs. Apply Vanicream as needed, including morning and night.
  4. 4In the morning, apply sunscreen after Vanicream and before makeup. Choose broad spectrum, water resistant SPF 30 or higher; these are the versions without sunscreen.
1257

What should you expect, and when should you get help?

Vanicream offers immediate hydration and softer, smoother skin with consistent use. CeraVe targets hydration through the night. Neither gives a specific number of days for resolving dryness. Both are labeled noncomedogenic, meaning formulated not to clog pores, rather than a promise of no breakouts.12

Tell a dermatologist if moisturizer causes burning, stinging or irritation. Get medical help if dryness persists despite self care, itching interrupts sleep, or scratching leaves open cuts or sores. If you already have a prescribed dry skin treatment plan, follow it rather than replacing it with a moisturizer swap.57

Where this answer comes from

  1. 1PM Facial Moisturizing Lotioncerave.com
  2. 2Vanicream™ Daily Facial Moisturizer for Sensitive Skinvanicream.com
  3. 3Cold weather and your skinaad.org
  4. 4Choosing the Best Moisturizer for Dry Skinhealth.clevelandclinic.org
  5. 5Dermatologists' top tips for relieving dry skinaad.org
  6. 6Dry Skin in Winter: 9 Tips To Keep Hydratedhealth.clevelandclinic.org
  7. 7Dry skin - self-care: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopediamedlineplus.gov